feat(proforge): measured supervisor quality gates + review-required label

components/proForge/ProForgeDashboard.tsx

@@ -86,11 +86,15 @@ export const ProForgeDashboard: React.FC = () => {
             <span className="text-[var(--sc-text-on-accent)] font-bold text-sm">P</span>
           </div>
           <div>
-            <div className="flex items-center gap-2">
+            <div className="flex items-center gap-2 flex-wrap">
               <h2 className="text-base font-semibold">{t('proforge.pipeline.title')}</h2>
               {/* QNBS-v3: ProForge is an on-by-default but experimental agentic pipeline — label it. */}
               <Badge variant="experimental">{t('common.badge.experimental')}</Badge>
             </div>
+            {/* QNBS-v3: PR6 — make the human-in-the-loop expectation explicit, not just implied in help. */}
+            <p className="text-[11px] text-[var(--sc-warning-fg)] font-medium">
+              {t('proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired')}
+            </p>
             <p className="text-xs text-[var(--sc-text-tertiary)]">
               {currentRun ? currentRun.label : t('proforge.pipeline.noneActive')}
             </p>

features/proForge/types.ts

@@ -95,8 +95,23 @@ export interface PipelineConfig {
   language: string;
   /** Max supervisor-triggered retries per stage (0 = no retry, 1 = one retry) */
   maxRetries?: 0 | 1;
+  /** Tunable supervisor quality-gate thresholds (defaults applied when omitted). */
+  qualityThresholds?: QualityThresholds;
 }
 
+/** Tunable thresholds for the heuristic supervisor quality gates. */
+export interface QualityThresholds {
+  /** Word count above which a stage producing zero edits/findings is treated as a fallback signal. */
+  largeManuscriptWords: number;
+  /** Intake qualityScore below this hard-fails the run. */
+  intakeHardGate: number;
+}
+
+export const DEFAULT_QUALITY_THRESHOLDS: QualityThresholds = {
+  largeManuscriptWords: 1000,
+  intakeHardGate: 30,
+};
+
 export const DEFAULT_PIPELINE_CONFIG: PipelineConfig = {
   genrePreset: 'general-fiction',
   selectedStages: [
@@ -117,6 +132,7 @@ export const DEFAULT_PIPELINE_CONFIG: PipelineConfig = {
   autoAcceptThreshold: 0,
   language: 'en',
   maxRetries: 1,
+  qualityThresholds: DEFAULT_QUALITY_THRESHOLDS,
 };
 
 // ---------------------------------------------------------------------------

locales/ar/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "جارٍ التحضير للعالم…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "جارٍ النظر في شكل قصتك…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "لا يوجد خط أنابيب نشط",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "تجريبي — مراجعتك مطلوبة؛ لا يتم تغيير المخطوطة أبدًا دون موافقتك.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "خط أنابيب المؤلّف الأمثل",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Active Stage",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ This stage is awaiting your review. Click the stage button above to review items.",

locales/de/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Macht sich für die Welt bereit…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Betrachtet die Struktur deiner Geschichte…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Keine aktive Pipeline",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Experimentell — deine Prüfung ist erforderlich; das Manuskript wird nie ohne deine Zustimmung geändert.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Ultimative Autoren-Pipeline",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Aktive Phase",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Diese Phase wartet auf Ihre Prüfung. Klicken Sie oben auf die Phasenschaltfläche, um die Einträge zu prüfen.",

locales/el/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Προετοιμασία για τον κόσμο…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Κοιτάζοντας τη μορφή της ιστορίας σας…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Δεν υπάρχει ενεργός αγωγός",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Πειραματικό — απαιτείται η αξιολόγησή σας· το χειρόγραφο δεν αλλάζει ποτέ χωρίς την έγκρισή σας.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Ultimate Author Pipeline",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Ενεργό Στάδιο",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Αυτό το στάδιο περιμένει την κριτική σας. Κάντε κλικ στο κουμπί του σταδίου παραπάνω για να ελέγξετε τα στοιχεία.",

locales/en/common.json

@@ -531,6 +531,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.analytics": "Summing up the run…",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Ultimate Author Pipeline",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "No active pipeline",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Experimental — your review is required; the manuscript is never changed without your approval.",
   "proforge.emptyState.title": "Your manuscript, refined.",
   "proforge.emptyState.description": "ProForge reads every chapter, then walks you through editing stage by stage. Nothing gets lost — every change is reversible.",
   "proforge.enabledHint": "ProForge Pipeline enabled. Open the Writer view and click the ProForge button in the tools panel to start.",

locales/es/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Preparándose para el mundo…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Observando la forma de tu historia…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Sin pipeline activa",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Experimental: se requiere tu revisión; el manuscrito nunca se modifica sin tu aprobación.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Ultimate Author Pipeline",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Etapa activa",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Esta etapa está esperando tu revisión. Haz clic en el botón de la etapa de arriba para revisar los elementos.",

locales/eu/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Mundurako prestatzen...",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Zure istorioaren formari begira...",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Ez dago kanalizazio aktiborik",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Esperimentala — zure berrikuspena beharrezkoa da; eskuizkribua ez da inoiz aldatzen zure oniritzirik gabe.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Azken egilearen kanalizazioa",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Etapa Aktiboa",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Etapa hau zure iritziaren zain dago. Egin klik goiko faseko botoian elementuak berrikusteko.",

locales/fa/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "آماده شدن برای جهان…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "با نگاه کردن به شکل داستان شما…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "بدون خط لوله فعال",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "آزمایشی — بازبینی شما لازم است؛ نسخه هرگز بدون تأیید شما تغییر نمی‌کند.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "خط لوله نویسنده نهایی",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "مرحله فعال",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ این مرحله منتظر بررسی شماست. برای بررسی موارد روی دکمه مرحله بالا کلیک کنید.",

locales/fi/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Valmistautuminen maailmaan…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Tarinasi muotoa katsoessani…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Ei aktiivista putkistoa",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Kokeellinen — tarkistuksesi vaaditaan; käsikirjoitusta ei koskaan muuteta ilman hyväksyntääsi.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Ultimate Author Pipeline",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Aktiivinen vaihe",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Tämä vaihe odottaa arvosteluasi. Napsauta yllä olevaa vaihepainiketta tarkastellaksesi kohteita.",

locales/fr/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Prêt pour le monde…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Examen de la structure de votre histoire…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Aucune pipeline active",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Expérimental — votre relecture est requise ; le manuscrit n'est jamais modifié sans votre accord.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Ultimate Author Pipeline",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Étape active",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Cette étape attend votre relecture. Cliquez sur le bouton de l'étape ci-dessus pour examiner les éléments.",

locales/he/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "מתכונן לעולם…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "מתבונן במבנה הסיפור שלכם…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "אין צינור פעיל",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "ניסיוני — נדרשת הבדיקה שלך; כתב היד לעולם לא משתנה ללא אישורך.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "צינור הסופר האולטימטיבי",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Active Stage",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ This stage is awaiting your review. Click the stage button above to review items.",

locales/hu/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Felkészülés a világra…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Elnézve a történeted alakját…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Nincs aktív csővezeték",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Kísérleti — szükség van az átnézésedre; a kézirat soha nem módosul a jóváhagyásod nélkül.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Ultimate Author Pipeline",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Aktív szakasz",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Ez a szakasz az értékelésedre vár. Kattintson a fenti szakasz gombra az elemek áttekintéséhez.",

locales/is/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Undirbúningur fyrir heiminn…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Þegar þú horfir á lögun sögunnar þinnar...",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Engin virk leiðsla",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Tilraunaverkefni — yfirferð þín er nauðsynleg; handritinu er aldrei breytt án samþykkis þíns.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Ultimate Author Pipeline",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Virkt stig",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Þetta stig bíður skoðunar þinnar. Smelltu á sviðshnappinn hér að ofan til að skoða atriði.",

locales/it/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Pronto per il mondo…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Osservando la forma della tua storia…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Nessuna pipeline attiva",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Sperimentale — è richiesta la tua revisione; il manoscritto non viene mai modificato senza la tua approvazione.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Ultimate Author Pipeline",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Fase attiva",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Questa fase è in attesa della tua revisione. Fai clic sul pulsante della fase qui sopra per esaminare gli elementi.",

locales/ja/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "世界に向けて準備中…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "あなたの物語の形を見てみると…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "アクティブなパイプラインがありません",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "実験的 — あなたのレビューが必要です。承認なしに原稿が変更されることはありません。",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "究極の著者パイプライン",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "アクティブステージ",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ このステージはあなたのレビューを待っています。項目を確認するには、上のステージ ボタンをクリックしてください。",

locales/ko/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "세상을 준비하는…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "이야기의 형태를 살펴보면…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "활성 파이프라인 없음",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "실험적 기능 — 검토가 필요합니다. 승인 없이 원고가 변경되지 않습니다.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "궁극적인 작성자 파이프라인",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "액티브 스테이지",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ 이 단계는 귀하의 검토를 기다리고 있습니다. 항목을 검토하려면 위의 단계 버튼을 클릭하세요.",

locales/pt/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Preparando-se para o mundo…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Olhando para a forma da sua história…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Nenhum pipeline ativo",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Experimental — a sua revisão é necessária; o manuscrito nunca é alterado sem a sua aprovação.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Pipeline final do autor",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Estágio Ativo",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Esta etapa aguarda sua análise. Clique no botão de estágio acima para revisar os itens.",

locales/ru/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Готовимся к миру…",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Глядя на форму вашей истории…",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Нет активного конвейера",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Экспериментально — требуется ваша проверка; рукопись никогда не изменяется без вашего одобрения.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Конечный авторский конвейер",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Активная стадия",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️Этот этап ожидает вашего рассмотрения. Нажмите кнопку этапа выше, чтобы просмотреть элементы.",

locales/sv/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "Förbereder sig för världen...",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "Titta på din berättelses form...",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "Ingen aktiv pipeline",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "Experimentell — din granskning krävs; manuskriptet ändras aldrig utan ditt godkännande.",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "Ultimate Author Pipeline",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "Aktiv scen",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️ Det här steget väntar på din recension. Klicka på scenknappen ovan för att granska objekt.",

locales/zh/common.json

@@ -327,6 +327,7 @@
   "proforge.loading.publishing": "为世界做好准备……",
   "proforge.loading.structural": "看看你的故事的形状……",
   "proforge.pipeline.noneActive": "无活动管道",
+  "proforge.pipeline.reviewRequired": "实验性功能——需要您审阅；未经您批准，稿件绝不会被修改。",
   "proforge.pipeline.title": "最终作者管道",
   "proforge.progress.activeStage": "活跃阶段",
   "proforge.progress.awaitingReviewHint": "⚠️此阶段正在等待您的审核。单击上面的阶段按钮以查看项目。",