Skip to content

Wiring PE to frame does nothing. #119

@cmdremily

Description

@cmdremily

On page 238 of the Trident assembly manual, the instructions show the PE being connected to the frame without further instruction.

While it is correct from an electrical safety standards point of view to connect any electrically conductive casing of a device to PE. In practice, the aluminium extrusions used on the absolute majority of builds are anodized and that makes the surface of the extrusion non-conductive (just like paint is). Don't trust me? Pick up a multi meter and measure two points on the surface of your nearest anodized extrusion. You'll find the surface has really poor electrical conductivity.

What this means is that simply screwing the PE wire to a roll-in t-nut on the frame (which is what I perceive as the intended solution) might not actually connect the frame to PE unless the bolt used scratches of the anodization and makes electrical contact this way. But there is no instruction to this end.

Furthermore, because of the blind joints design, it's likely but not guaranteed that extrusions that are joined make electrical contact via either the screw and the exposed aluminium in the non-threaded through hole or by scratching the anodization of the non-threaded extrusion. Again, subject to if the screws are anodized themselves. In my build, they do make electrical contact with the exception of the back side horizontal member between the A/B motor mounts.

I would like to see this section of the manual improved to mention both the recommended fastening technique (as it's not obvious to many people that the extrusion isn't conductive) and to use a multimeter to check conductivity from various frame elements to the PE connection (e.g. PSU casing).

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions