Skip to content

Commit bcbe022

Browse files
haarerhaarer
authored andcommitted
update summary and actions
1 parent 021c95b commit bcbe022

1 file changed

Lines changed: 6 additions & 8 deletions

File tree

reports/concern-duplicates-analysis.md

Lines changed: 6 additions & 8 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -180,7 +180,6 @@ These concerns exist in the catalog but have no viewpoints associated with them.
180180
| *What is the allocated reliability for the complete item?* | reliability |
181181
| *What is the sequence of interactions among the system and context elements on physical level?* | interaction |
182182
| *How do the conceptual system elements interact to provide the system functions?* | interaction |
183-
| *What are the items exchanged between conceptual system elements during an interaction?* | interaction |
184183

185184
**Recommendation:** Either assign these to appropriate viewpoints or deprecate them.
186185

@@ -204,17 +203,16 @@ Some concerns appear to be assigned to the wrong owner domain.
204203
|---|---|
205204
| Total concerns analyzed | 141 |
206205
| HIGH confidence duplicate pairs | 3 groups (~7 concerns) |
207-
| MEDIUM confidence conceptual/physical pairs | 8 pairs (~16 concerns) |
208-
| Exchange item fragmentation | 7 concerns → 2 recommended |
209-
| Orphaned concerns (no viewpoint) | 8+ |
206+
| Conceptual/physical pairs (deliberate — keep separate) | 8 pairs (~16 concerns) |
207+
| Exchange item concerns (3 categories × 2 levels, valid structure) | 8 |
208+
| Orphaned concerns (no viewpoint) | 6 (4 reliability + 2 interaction) |
210209
| Categorization mismatches | 3 |
211210

212211
### Priority Actions
213212

214213
1. **Merge functional decomposition concerns** (1.1) — trivial, clear win.
215214
2. **Merge functional scope concerns** (1.2) — same viewpoint, same intent.
216215
3. **Collapse the framework grid concerns** (1.3) — three into one.
217-
4. **Parameterize conceptual vs. physical** across all affected pairs — reduces concern count by ~8 while preserving semantic fidelity.
218-
5. **Collapse exchange item fragmentation** (2.6) — 7 concerns → 2.
219-
6. **Assign or deprecate orphaned concerns** — especially the 4 reliability concerns that have zero viewpoint coverage.
220-
7. **Fix categorization mismatches** — move 3 concerns to appropriate owners.
216+
4. **Investigate #1 vs #2 in exchange items** (2.6) — these are the only two occupying the same cell (conceptual + identification); everything else in that section is structurally justified.
217+
5. **Assign or deprecate orphaned concerns** — especially the 4 reliability concerns that have zero viewpoint coverage.
218+
6. **Fix categorization mismatches** — move 3 concerns to appropriate owners.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)